RaleighRancher wrote:As I understand it, older DS's had a pivot bolt that went all the way through the CB trunk, with large rubber washers and stainless washers to seal the hole. (This was the case on a 1974 Javelin I used to have.)
You mean older DS2s. That design is problematic because it tends to leak.
Even older, on the DS1s, you have a one-sided washer because the side opposite the handle simply rested in a sort of divot in the CB trunk. That didn't work as intended so many owners drilled a hole, tapped the pivot bolt and added bolt and washer on the side opposite the handle. That better secures the CB but now you have two places that can leak. In the DS1 the bilge is open, so it's easy to monitor.
The earliest DS2s built on that at first, but then people realized that with up and dowhaul, you don't actually need to penetrate into the hull as there's no lever to turn the pivot. Hence the wedges.
As you've discovered, that design, if caulked, doesn't leak, but the uphaul can create massive leaks both into the hull and into the cuddy, while underway. The first is addressed by the nipple fix for a secure and watertight connection between trunk and liner. There is some best practice for the other, but it escapes me at the moment.
My DS2 skipper was content with a massive leak draining into the cockpit, but he was happy to bail underway, rather than find a way to limit or eliminate that leak from the uphaul opening.